Best Wing Spots in Indiana - Page 3

Source: http://www.bettycrocker.com / http://www.bettycrocker.com

Best Wing Spots in Indiana

It’s National Chicken Wing Day, and what better way to celebrate than by spotlighting the best places to get your fingers saucy across the Hoosier state?

Whether you like them grilled, smoked, spicy, or sweet—Indiana’s wing scene runs deep with flavor, creativity, and serious local pride.

From hole-in-the-wall gems to sports bars that double as wing sanctuaries, there’s something for every kind of chicken lover here.

Whether you’re debating flats vs. drums or arguing over ranch vs. bleu cheese, one thing we can all agree on is that a good wing joint can bring people together. And in Indiana, the community doesn’t play about its chicken.

Some spots serve up classic Buffalo-style with the perfect crisp, while others take bold risks with smoked, Korean-fried, or sweet-and-spicy fusion options that hit every craving at once.

To honor this delicious holiday, we scoured Yelp reviews, Reddit threads, and our own taste buds to round up the Top 5 Wing Spots in Indiana.

From Indianapolis icons like Ale Emporium and Chatham Tap to newer contenders and underrated gems, these are the places that consistently deliver on crunch, flavor, and fire.

Whether you’re a lifelong local or just passing through, let this list guide your next bite.

1. Ale Emporium (Indianapolis / Fishers / Greenwood)

• Consistently praised as one of Indy’s best wing destinations.

• Their Hermanaki wings—a grilled/breaded style tossed in a signature sweet-hot “Herman” sauce—get rave reviews. Redditors and food writers alike highlight the grilled texture and bold flavor, often rating them around 4.5/5 .

• Snack portion six wings for about $12 (~$2/wing)

2. Chatham Tap (Indianapolis)

• Home of “Prince Dean’s Angel” wings tossed in a house‑made sweet‑spicy sauce, frequently named “fave” on Yelp and Reddit .

• Fans call it their go‑to spot for wings—especially if you enjoy a slightly sweeter buffalo profile.

• Regularly tops local best‑of lists for traditional sauced wings in Indy

3. Keystone Sports Review

• Known for classic, saucy, messy buffalo‑style wings with great blue‑cheese and ranch options

• Frequently appears in Reddit top‑wing rankings alongside Chatham Tap and Ale Emporium.

4. Fat Dan’s (Broad Ripple / Indianapolis)

• Specializes in smoked wings, giving them a distinct depth of flavor and texture.

• Reddit users consistently mention Fat Dan’s for “best smoked wings” in the city

5. Tom’s Watch Bar

• A newer entrant, earning a 4/5 rating in local reviews for its buffalo and standout Korean BBQ wings .

• Great atmosphere for sports fans—especially if you’re in the mood for wings with exciting flavors.