Best Chili Spots in Indianapolis to Warm Up This Fall

A true Indy institution since 1974, Nick’s Chili Parlor is often the first name locals think of when it comes to chili. Their 5-Way Chili (spaghetti, beans, onions, cheddar, and chili) is a fan favorite, but they also serve it over hot dogs for a quicker fix. Old-school, affordable, and loaded with Hoosier charm.

Known as one of the best burger joints in the city, Workingman’s Friend also quietly serves a killer bowl of chili. It’s hearty, flavorful, and the perfect companion to their legendary double cheeseburger. The no-frills, cash-only vibe makes it a true Indy classic.

This cozy English-style pub doesn’t just brew good beer—it’s also known for its chili. They offer both a meat version and a vegetarian option, making it one of the few spots in Indy where everyone at the table can enjoy a bowl. Perfect for a chilly fall evening.

While Cincinnati-style chili isn’t originally Hoosier, Skyline has carved out a strong following in Indianapolis. Their spaghetti-based chili dishes topped with mountains of shredded cheddar are unique and addictive. It’s not traditional Indiana chili, but it’s worth the detour if you want something different.

Another Cincinnati-style option in Indy, Gold Star is Skyline’s spicy cousin. The chili here leans a little more robust in flavor, and locals love debating which chain does it better. If you’re a chili fan, it’s worth trying both.

A longtime staple on the west side, John’s has been serving bowls of thick, hearty beef stew and chili since 1911. If you want old-school comfort food with serious flavor, this is the spot.

Located downtown, Loughmiller’s is a popular pre-game and lunch spot that serves up a thick, flavorful chili topped with shredded cheddar and onions. It’s a go-to for Colts fans on game day.